Blog

The Uberesquing of general practice

I’m hitting retirement as a rural doctor after 45 years with a plethora of trusts, companies and other business entities that were hugely expensive to establish and maintain, and which will be horribly expensive to unravel, more so if Labor’s trust changes are legislated.  
Accountants should charge the taxation department for their client advice, as the ATO is the real ongoing beneficiary of all these structures and schemes.  
The joys of practice ownership. But is the independent contractor, gig worker model really the alternative? 
Someone said to me recently: “Question – what’s the difference between an independent contractor GP and an employee? Answer – about a million-dollar lifetime spend on accountants, legal and business advisors”.  
The independent contractor model in medicine is often depicted as an escape from the reality of practice ownership.  
But while it has its role, and some organisations structured as management services companies do it very well, it is a refuge that has consequences, both for practitioners, future workforce and the quality and delivery of health services. 
What the current generation of medical lifestyle seekers don’t seem to realise, is that even with high billing percentages and hourly rates, they are still gig workers.  
And as gig workers they might avoid responsibilities of practice ownership, but ultimately they deny themselves the opportunity to build a business that has intrinsic and extrinsic value.  
As independent contractors, there aren’t any real benefits of owning their own practice; and as pseudo-employees they have none of the entitlements of employment.  

Related   

Is the dominance of Best Practice a good or a bad thing?

Discretionary trust tax changes are going to bite doctors

What doctors need to know about discretionary trust changes

The independent contractor model has been rigorously defended by those who benefit, and those who don’t know any better.  
Originally spawned by Geoffrey Edelsten as a means of avoiding legal liability and payroll tax, it has been copied by almost every small general practice and supported by the RACGP and AMA during the recent, but ongoing debate, about payroll tax.  
But as GPs are commanding more percentage income and government changes to Medicare and the PIP, with increased rebates and bulk-billing incentives, effectively feeding the dragon, smaller, independent practices are missing out.  
Geography determines distribution needs for health care.  
Australia is built on a few capital cities and major centres, but also on many remote communities, small towns and regional centres.  
Large, consolidated practices are often not an option in these communities. So smaller practices are not optional. They cannot compete in the GP market, the efficiencies in larger practices are just too great.  
So where have all the GPs gone? Well. they’re doing less work, for one thing, putting in fewer hours in patient face to face time, as they can achieve a target income earlier.  
And for Australian trained graduates, there is an increasing focus on specialties that support lifestyle demands, such as salaried emergency medicine.  
The reality, also, is that the current independent contractor engagement in general practice model is actually causing a shift in sentiment away from general practice.  
Graduates now are attracted to certainty and lifestyle imperatives. They do not see themselves as gig workers working with a percentage, having to push through patients to earn a compensation, without the benefits of employment. 
The High Court has just ruled that payments made by Uber to its drivers were subject to payroll tax. Commentators (for example in The Australian 5 November – “Ubers $81m tax hit set to spread”) are suggesting that this will have implications for “other gig economy platforms across health, transport and hospitality sectors”.  
You can believe it. Payroll tax is a horrible tax, but it is the largest single source of state-collected tax revenue in NSW. It is around 26-27% of total state tax take.  
So the mistake the profession made was to seek relief from the tax for doctors, but not argue with other groups for the need to shift the base. 
Whenever we try to argue for change, solely out of self-interest, the arguments lose their credibility, and credibility is not a renewable resource. 
There’s a further dimension to it. Relief from payroll tax in some states was predicated on practices reaching a threshold proportion of bulk billing.  
The states effectively (and predictably) used the profession’s argument, that “fees would have to go up” if practices had to pay payroll tax, against them.  
But now, with practices rushing into the BBPIP incentive, and stretched state budgets, I surmise there will be little motivation for states to provide that relief into the future 
Unlike prominent medical financial advisors, and while not providing financial advice, I have been warning practices (at no cost) to be fully informed about their exposure with regard to payroll tax, since 2010.  
In this year, our accrediting company got caught by the state payroll tax harmonisation rules. We spent tens of thousands of dollars on accounting and legal advice, most of it reactive or poor.  
In the end we made the easy decision just to go with an employment model for all surveyors.  
The future of general practice is not a total gig worker model.  
Access, affordability and equity in delivering coordinated patient care, and a satisfying professional career, depends on working out how we can make private practice ownership more attractive and effective, while supporting a diversity of engagement models, including employment options. 
Dr Paul Mara is a rural GP and founder of Quality Practice Accreditation.  
The post The Uberesquing of general practice appeared first on Medical Republic.

About the author

Asonblog

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment