Introduction by Croakey: The American Public Health Association has blamed the leadership of the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) for the United States losing its measles elimination status, following outbreaks of the highly infectious disease affecting several thousand people across the country over the past two years.
The Association said the decision, announced officially on 17 November by the Pan American Health Organization, was no surprise given the vaccine disinformation that had been circulating.
“A national call to vaccinate to slow the spread of the infectious disease, especially as outbreaks emerged in 2025, would have prevented this,” said the Association in a statement.
“Instead of choosing to take such preventative measures to keep communities healthy and maintain the nation’s elimination status, HHS leadership allowed unscientific ideas and talking points to guide important decision-making, leading to a web of confusion and heartbreaking loss.
“If communities can no longer count on HHS leadership to put forth evidence-based guidance to promptly respond to the ongoing outbreak, we will see more kids missing school, along with unnecessary hospitalisations and deaths.”
In early 2025, The Lancet published a prescient warning that the appointment of vaccine sceptic Robert F Kennedy Jr as HHS Secretary could prove “catastrophic”, as it coincided with a resurgence of measles cases and growing vaccine hesitancy spurred by pandemic-era disruptions.
The rise of preventable illnesses and deaths is just one of many ways the Trump Administration has undermined public health and the wider determinants of health, as Croakey has documented since early 2025.
During the week of the midterms, Croakey published responses from 13 health and community leaders considering the implications of the results for health, globally and in the US.
Below, we continue the series, including a focus on the Victorian election, with comments from:
Dr Sue Wareham OAM: “Prospects now look brighter for candidates whose policies address the needs of all, while celebrating diversity, and who demand urgent action to reduce climate change and other big threats.”
Lyn Morgain AM: “Regulation of rampant and unfettered corporate interests, efforts to promote labour organising and environmental protection are all important health measures.”
Professor Cath Chamberlain: “The big lesson for Australia is what not to do, how valuable democracy is, how grateful we should be for compulsory voting, and the importance of good government.”
Edwina Pearse: “Humour and hope are not distractions from serious politics. They can help people imagine themselves as part of something.”
Cut US military spending
Dr Sue Wareham OAM, President, Medical Association for the Prevention of War
Q: What is your immediate response to the results?
There is a huge sense of relief that there will now be greater constraints on a man who has brought so much suffering to so many people in the US and elsewhere. This is extremely good news.
However, we shouldn’t have any false sense of security about the extent of any change that might come, or when it might come.
A key focus of MAPW concerns about the US is its obsession with military power at the expense of every form of genuine “security”, such as a healthy environment, stable climate and a population that is economically secure. These distorted priorities were exacerbated by President Trump, but were not created by him.
New ways of thinking will be needed to start replacing the god of corporate profit with values that serve people and the planet. This will need a Congress prepared to rein in the influence of industries that cause immense harm to health and to human security, such as the fossil fuel and weapons industries.
The new Congress restores hope that change is at least possible. Now the hard work of making it happen begins.
Q: If you could give advice to the new Congress (to be sworn in on 3 January, 2027) about what to do now for US and global health, what would it be?
MAPW’s advice to the new Congress would be, firstly, to take the urgent steps needed to prevent a US president, current or future, from having sole authority to launch a nuclear weapons attack.
The current situation, where the actions of one person can threaten civilisation as we know it, is extremely perilous. In addition, urgent steps must be taken to resume nuclear arms control measures with US adversaries.
Similarly, engagement of the US with global climate action is urgently needed.
A major reduction of US military spending, and cutting military aid to Israel, would not only improve prospects for peace in the Middle East and elsewhere, but would free up large sums of money for healthcare, education and other much needed priorities. A guarantee of the best available healthcare for all citizens would be possible. US funding for development aid and for UN and other important global institutions should be restored.
Q: Will the results have any bearing upon Australian politics – for example, the upcoming Victorian election?
We can cautiously hope that the politics of fear, hatred and division – within Australia and with other nations – are starting to fail.
Prospects now look brighter for candidates whose policies address the needs of all, while celebrating diversity, and who demand urgent action to reduce climate change and other big threats. This is extremely heartening, and these candidates will be watched closely.
Quotes from previous Croakey article: https://www.croakey.org/experts-draw-wide-ranging-lessons-from-the-blue-wave/
Be bold and act authentically
Health and community leader Lyn Morgain AM
Q: What is a standout moment for you from the results?
Dr Abdul El-Sayed saying that Trump could call him Senator.
Q: If you could give advice to the new Congress about what to do now for US and global health, what would it be?
Restore respect for the rule of law. Get money out of politics by moving on campaign finance reform. Restore the health of the democracy. Tax billionaires. Prosecute the human rights abuses of ICE and against Trans people and reproductive rights. Unshackle advocacy organisations and other contributors to healthy democratic transparency, accountability and debates.
Then rejoin as equals the rapidly reshaping multilateral agencies, the UN and others. Contribute to these with integrity. Restore respect for the scientific community, WHO and the myriad critical apparatus of surveillance, cooperation, distribution, prevention and equity that drive and make possible, global cooperation for health.
Q: What are the challenges and opportunities for global health and security from the outcomes?
A reorganis(ing) world order. The effect of the COVID pandemic on financial markets and experience of vaccine (in)equity across the world further exacerbated gross and existential global inequities. This, coupled with the escalation in the scale and ferocity of conflict, in which NATO countries are involved, and the existential threats of the climate crisis, have driven legitimate demands for a revitalised and reimagined multilateral system. One that genuinely provides for the full democratic participation of all relevant interests. And affords equal rights to its members. Shaping a different role for the historical players of the west.
The US has the opportunity to both contribute to this transition and at the same time achieve a re-set on its own record of insolence. Making a genuine contribution to a strong and authentic multilateral system, models expectations of global citizens. The US does not need to be the leader, to model global standards.
Health systems of all types require a commitment to a rules-based order. This rehabilitation is essential then to the (health) security of the US and global communities.
Communities must have control over resources sufficient to meet their needs and be afforded their right to equality dignity and cultural expression. Regulation of rampant and unfettered corporate interests, efforts to promote labour organising and environmental protection are all important health measures.
Q: Will the results have any bearing upon Australian politics – for example, the upcoming Victorian election?
Yes and no. There is already significant American influence on Australian politics through the global interests of billionaire classes and media interests, amplified through the opportunity of disinformation and digital media, that’s not new.
Also, through evangelical church movements that we have seen fund and promote so-called family values candidates and align with mining and other resource sectors, to influence public policy and electoral outcomes.
What has changed and will in time influence Australian politics is the shape of the prevailing interests. These are plainly democratic socialist values getting elected in the US Mid Terms. This will embolden and ignite youth and progressive movements here, as others have done globally. It will drive an ethos of international solidarity.
The present and in a sense anomalous rise of One Nation here and in this Victorian election has been comprehensively demonstrated to be about disaffection. Driven plainly it seems, by social and economic neglect of especially regional communities, the face of which has been comprehensively documented over the past 30 years.
The degradation and punification (sic) of our social security system has comprehensively bitten present governments (with or without mandates) on the bum. Recklessly this has also provided fertile ground for confected and racist narratives about who gets what. These are narratives that unquestionably diminish public safety and expose communities to risk.
I do admire the ALP propensity for big visionary change. Recognising the necessity for Treaty being an outstanding example. The Big Build perhaps less so. And NDIS as an example of how it’s hard.
Critically, however, the failure of the Victorian Government’s federal counterparts to address embedded poverty, income inequality and access to services in this country, for single parents, the un and under-employed, people with disability and so on. Is Alongside coal and gas, that is this Government’s single greatest policy problem – eroding economic prosperity, producing crime and driving significant burden of disease.
Turns out it also gives One Nation a free kick. In which being different, is enough.
Q: Do you have any thoughts for how the results could inform public health and health equity advocacy in Australia or elsewhere?
This result, Texas, Mississippi and so on, have been described by insiders as a ‘spiritual change of heart’ in these voter communities. What these commentators are reflecting here is the seismic nature of what has happened, what motivated it and the reason I too think we need to pay attention.
Black voters and black women in particular, organised themselves and others and produced record breaking results, everywhere. And they did so without any of the usual back up, campaign financing and in a number of cases without even the support of their own parties.
Their power was in the unshakable commitment to simple rights-based values. About genocide, about healthcare, about malfeasance, about war.
So, the lesson here is in some respects simple, we need to recognise in this result the power and possibility of organising, around values. Something Americans have historically by necessity, learnt to be very good at. They do after all need to ‘get out the vote’.
What happened in this result demonstrates that traditional support and structures are not necessary to win and win big.
I do think the power of this wave, as with others like it, occurring globally, is to inspire present political movements to be bold and act authentically for the interests of their communities. These were not ordinary candidates, and this was not an ordinary election. This is a bigger change.
Quotes from previous Croakey article: https://www.croakey.org/experts-draw-wide-ranging-lessons-from-the-blue-wave/
Relief – and anxiety
Professor Cath Chamberlain, a Trawlwoolway (Palawa) woman, registered midwife and public health researcher and Professor of Indigenous Health, University of Melbourne
As many people must also be feeling, it’s a huge relief. But I still have a lot of anxiety as the results don’t curb President Trump’s capacity to continue to reap military havoc, death and destruction.
This is an ongoing risk to global health and security; as many have observed, when Trump is feeling angry and insecure, who knows what he might do.
I hope the Democrats can use the opportunity to deliver for working class people, as they are suffering more than those in any other high income country. They are being completely exploited as workers, are facing even more job insecurity with AI, huge healthcare costs and challenges. It is just unconscionable that people should be living like that in such a rich country in GDP terms.
My understanding is there’s a limit to how much Congress can do in terms of global health progress as Trump can still exercise his veto powers. But they can still propose progress, like on climate change, restoring the Centers for Disease Control.
Hopefully Congress can veto any further loosening of regulation of big tech, and also any more dangerous initiatives from Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr.
The big lesson for Australia is what not to do, how valuable democracy is, how grateful we should be for compulsory voting, and the importance of good government.
Quotes from previous Croakey article: https://www.croakey.org/experts-draw-wide-ranging-lessons-from-the-blue-wave/
Delighted but not relaxed
Edwina Pearse, a Melbourne-based communications strategist specialising in public health, advocacy, and social change
Q. What is your immediate response to the results?
Relief, delight and a renewed sense of possibility. What heartens me is the reminder that although money can buy extraordinary influence, it cannot guarantee victory. I certainly don’t mean to underestimate its power, but people can still organise, act collectively and refuse the idea that the wealthiest interests get to determine what happens next.
For me, this is about agency. The money matters and the obstacles are real, but that does not mean the outcome is already decided. There is still power in people choosing to work together for something better.
Q: What is a standout moment for you from the results?
I have enjoyed watching the so-called millennial candidates and the different ways they connect with people. The fan edits, the humour, the internet crushes. There is something refreshing about politicians who seem comfortable allowing personality and serious purpose to coexist.
What interests me from a communications perspective is their willingness to embrace that enthusiasm rather than distance themselves from it. They do not seem embarrassed by the possibility that people might find them appealing, or that political communication can be entertaining as well as substantive.
Some of that appeal is about competence, conviction and being able to communicate. Being prepared, listening carefully and holding powerful people to account are qualities worth admiring. I like seeing those qualities become part of popular culture, rather than assuming that serious politics must always look and sound a particular way.
Q: Do you have any thoughts for how the results could inform public health and health equity advocacy in Australia or elsewhere?
I don’t think the lesson is that public health advocates need to turn themselves into internet personalities. It is that we could be more curious about what makes people stop, listen, care and share.
We can become so concerned with being credible that we forget to be engaging. Meeting people where they are, including in the places they go for entertainment and connection, does not have to mean compromising the substance of what we say.
There is also something important about giving people a reason to participate beyond fear and obligation. We ask a lot of people when we invite them to keep paying attention to harm, injustice and the possibility of things getting worse. We should also give them something to move towards, and a sense that their contribution matters.
Humour and hope are not distractions from serious politics. They can help people imagine themselves as part of something.
Q: Will the results have any bearing upon Australian politics – for example, the upcoming Victorian election?
I would be cautious about drawing a straight line between an American election and how Victorians will vote, but I hope there is encouragement here for Australian politics and advocacy.
We do not have to assume that resentment and division are the only effective ways to reach people. We can take people’s frustrations seriously without finding someone else to blame and offer a politics that is both practical and generous about who belongs.
I would like to see more confidence in that possibility here, rather than treating the accommodation of divisive politics as an electoral necessity.
I’m also nervous about Trump’s next move. I suspect gracious reflection is not on the agenda, and Stephen Miller’s appointment as White House Chief of Staff isn’t exactly helping me sleep. So I’m still and mostly delighted, just not quite relaxed.
Quotes from previous Croakey article: https://www.croakey.org/experts-draw-wide-ranging-lessons-from-the-blue-wave/
Further reading
• The Guardian: ‘A complete repudiation’: public health won big in US midterm elections
• Amanda Tattersall on Substack: “Healthy political ecologies don’t eliminate difference. They find ways for different strategies to coexist, challenge one another and sometimes reinforce each other’s power. They also remind us of something even more fundamental: people power is much bigger than any political party, electoral coalition or elected office. Elections matter enormously. But democracy is much more than elections. It is reproduced through the many different ways people come together to exercise power, including when they disagree about how to make change.”
• Columbia Journalism Review. Misread Mandate: Donald Trump never had the authority, or the political support, media moguls seemed to think he did. What’s next for the outlets that capitulated?
• Croakey Health Media: Experts draw wide-ranging lessons from the “blue wave”
See Croakey’s archive of articles on the Trump Administration and health











Add Comment