Blog

Improving hospital productivity starts with honest health budgets

Introduction by Croakey: Concerning trends in the allocation of health funding were documented in a recent edition of The Zap. The latest national data on health spending shows that while spending on hospital services increased in real terms by four percent in the year to 2024-2025, spending on primary care, including public health, increased by just 1.2 percent.
Meanwhile, the health expenditure gap between rural and urban Australians is widening, according to a report released by the National Rural Health Alliance that found each rural Australian is receiving, on average, $1,218 less in healthcare funding each year than city residents.
As so many have been saying for so long, we need to invest in and strengthen prevention and primary healthcare, which requires focus and funding commitments beyond hospitals.
Reforming hospital budgeting arrangements might help to lay a foundation for the wider reforms needed, suggests the analysis below by Peter Breadon and Thomas Shortridge from the Grattan Institute.

Peter Breadon and Thomas Shortridge write:
A year waiting for a knee replacement can mean a year of pain, poor sleep, and difficulty getting around. If your knee doesn’t get worse while you wait, your mental health might, and your family’s might too.
Too many Australians endure that kind of waitlist purgatory. In 2024–25, six percent of patients admitted from public hospital elective surgery waiting lists had waited more than a year. That’s about three times the pre-pandemic rate.
Rising demand and rising costs could mean even longer waits for patients, and they will definitely deliver bigger bills for governments.
The federal Treasury’s latest Intergenerational Report, published in September, sounded the alarm on growing healthcare costs.
Grattan Institute analysis shows state hospital spending is still outstripping budgets. And a recent Grattan report, Budget reboot, sets out reforms to strengthen state finances.
Together, they show why governments must reset hospital budgets now.
Budget busters
Hospitals are already struggling to provide timely care, and doing so will only get harder as the population gets older. The Intergenerational Report projects that health will remain the biggest pressure on the federal budget.
Over the next 40 years, the share of the economy that goes to federal health spending is expected to increase by more than half, with most of the increase going to public hospitals.
State budgets will be under even more pressure, since the states pay more of the public hospital bill but raise less tax revenue to pay for it.
Governments can reduce the need for hospital care by improving prevention and primary care, and by making sure aged care beds are ready for elderly patients who are ready for discharge from hospital.
But even if everything goes right outside hospitals, we can expect more demand for hospital care, new treatments, and rising costs. That’s why care inside hospitals must be as efficient as possible.

More care for every dollar
There is a lot of room for improvement. Grattan Institute’s 2025 report, Smarter spending, found big differences in costs between hospitals, even after adjusting for patient and hospital characteristics.
In Victoria, for example, the average cost of a knee replacement varied by almost $14,000 across different hospitals.
We estimated that bringing higher-cost hospitals back to the middle of the pack in their state could free up about $1.2 billion a year. That’s enough to pay for about 160,000 additional hospital admissions.
But that’s just the prize for catching up to today’s average performer. With the right incentives and support, even the most efficient hospitals could keep getting better, and the gains could mount year after year.
There are plenty of safe ways to get more care for the same cost. Hospitals can consolidate back-of-house functions, such as procurement. States can hire temporary doctors centrally, or cap what hospitals pay them, to stop hospitals bidding up the cost of temporary staff.
Some ways of cutting costs can even improve care. Helping suitable patients go home on the day of surgery, reducing preventable complications such as falls and infections, and concentrating some surgeries in specialised, high-volume centres can all make care safer as well as cheaper.
For all these examples, there are huge differences between leading and lagging hospitals, even within the same state.
If these best practices make financial sense, and can often improve care, why haven’t they spread through the system?
Beyond bogus budgets
Budgets aren’t just about bean counting. They underpin productivity by giving hospitals the incentive to save, and the funding to invest in better ways of working. But state hospital budgets are often fiscal fantasies.
Governments routinely set them too low, then top up funding at the last minute when the money runs out. It’s a cycle known as “soft budgeting”, and international evidence shows that it leads to higher costs.
When hospitals expect a bailout, efficiency becomes a low priority. If they do want to improve, the funding rollercoaster makes it hard to invest in new ways of working.
When hospitals blow past unrealistic budgets, governments can’t hold them to account, so the cycle repeats.
New data published in Grattan Institute’s Budget reboot report show that health spending exceeded budgets in about seven out of 10 years in the four states assessed. That was more often than any other portfolio, even with COVID-affected years excluded.
Health spending may be harder to predict than the cost of running schools, but governments can do much better.
Our Smarter spending report found that simply extending long-term spending trends predicted hospital spending more accurately than state budgets.
There is no sign that the trend is turning around.
In our 2025 report, we found that hospital spending exceeded state budgets in most states, in most years, over the previous decade.
Since then, there’s been yet another round of blown budgets. In 2025-26, five of the six states with available data overspent again, by an average of six percent, with only Tasmania coming in under budget.

Get real
Grattan Institute’s new report, Budget reboot, shows how to build discipline into state budgeting.
States should set clear debt-reduction goals, and spending targets to achieve them. Strong, independent state budget offices should advise on the targets and publicly report on progress.
Governments should regularly review every major area of spending and let agencies reinvest a share of the savings they achieve.
Once statewide budgeting is credible, realistic hospital budgets can follow. Then those budgets can come with consequences, both good and bad.
Hospitals that break even and meet their performance targets should get three-year budgets rather than one-year budgets, and keep their surpluses to reinvest.
Struggling hospitals should get help to improve, but persistent, substantial deficits should trigger escalating consequences, ultimately including the replacement of CEOs and boards.
Under the new national health funding deal, governments have committed to boost public hospital productivity. That includes funding new models of care and developing pricing incentives for more efficient care, such as safe same-day surgery.
But without credible budgets, these reforms will be set up to fail.
New incentives to promote efficiency will fight the perverse incentives of soft budgeting. Combined with better budgeting, the reforms will create a triple win: strong and resilient state finances, reliable funding for the care Australians need, and a hospital system that becomes more efficient over time.
The Intergenerational Report asks us to confront the cost of care over the next four decades. But governments can only do that if they start with honest hospital budgets for the next four quarters.

Further reading
Croakey: Australia’s “health reform” agreement still treats illness, rather than supporting health

See Croakey’s archive of articles on health financing

About the author

Asonblog

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment