Blog

Victoria’s health debate shouldn’t stop at the hospital door

Introduction by Croakey: Victorians are fortunate to have community health services, which provide state-funded primary healthcare and focus on people at increased risk of poorer health.
However, these services are under increasing pressure from rising demand and funding constraints – so why aren’t they centre stage during the state election campaign?
The Labor Party, Coalition and Victorian Greens have expressed support for the sector, according to comments reported from the Victorian Healthcare Association’s recent conference.
However, the VHA’s election commitment tracker shows that only the Greens have made an explicit commitment to increase spending on community health services – to three percent of health and health infrastructure budgets – while hospital funding commitments generally dominate election promises.
The Victorian leaders debate this week again kept the health policy focus largely on hospitals. It did not highlight the community health sector’s role in keeping people well, reducing demand on hospitals, and ensuring access to care, especially at a time of concern about healthcare costs and cost-of-living pressures.
Below, two community health leaders, Anna Robinson and Natalie Sullivan, call for a greater political and public focus on their sector. “For the cost of building one new hospital bed, community health could deliver over 20,000 hours of care that ultimately keeps people from needing to go to hospital,” they write.

Anna Robinson and Natalie Sullivan write:
Community health is one of the least-known parts of the Victorian health system. It is also busier than ever before.
In the past year, over 736,000 Victorians turned to community health for support, around one in 10 Victorians. Demand for low-cost care has skyrocketed as cost-of-living pressures see more people seeking out affordable allied health, general practice, and mental health support.
So why isn’t community health an election issue?
Because its greatest successes are invisible: the hospital visit avoided, the crisis prevented, the person who stays well at home. You can’t cut a ribbon on prevention or put an avoided admission on a billboard.
So the health debate has barely looked past the hospital door.
As in many elections before it, billions have been pledged for hospitals this campaign.
But more money is not a guaranteed fix. Despite record investment in Victorian hospitals over the last few years, we’ve not seen commensurate improvement in patient outcomes.
Population growth, an ageing population and rising rates of chronic disease are only going to increase the pressure on acute care unless something changes.
The problem is that our system drives demand towards hospitals and then creates unmanageable pressure points. Without access to services that prevent illness from escalating and help people understand and manage their health, people end up in hospital when things reach crisis point.
Pouring more money into the consequence rather than the cause keeps the public conversation stuck on a health system under stress, because people can see it isn’t working. Hospitals are still full, staff are still burnt out, waiting lists are getting longer and ambulance ramping is getting worse.
Crisis prevention
If supply can’t keep up with demand, we need to reduce demand. That means lowering the number of people that need to go to hospital in the first place.
This is where community health comes in.
This is not about new money. It is about where the existing money is spent.
Victoria does not need to spend more to get a better health system. It needs to use the current budget more wisely.
When we talk about health only in terms of hospital beds, we are talking about the most expensive part of the system, and the point at which people are often at their sickest. When we focus the attention and money here, we see hospital budgets going up year on year.
Rather than accept this as inevitable, there is a case for making better use of the health dollars available and reducing hospital demand by improving prevention and primary care funding.
A sustainable health system empowers individuals and communities to improve and take control of their health, helps people understand their own health risks better, keeps people well, catches problems early, and supports people to manage their health over the long term at home.
Right now, the Community Health Program receives just 0.42 percent of Victoria’s health budget. Yet our programs have been shown to improve people’s health and wellbeing, keep them out of hospital and save the system up to $13 in avoided future costs for every dollar spent.
For the cost of building one new hospital bed, community health could deliver over 20,000 hours of care that ultimately keeps people from needing to go to hospital. Preventable emergency department presentations already cost Victoria’s health system more than $500 million a year.
Every health dollar is a choice. Governments can keep funding care at the point of crisis or invest in affordable care that stops people reaching crisis in the first place.
Community health services are critical infrastructure. Photo provided.
Success story
Community health is a Victorian success story. We should be embracing what it has to offer.
For more than 50 years, independent community health organisations have delivered care in their local communities, from Mildura to Preston to Lakes Entrance. Today, 21 organisations employ close to 11,000 people.
For many people, community health is the first place they turn. For some, it is the only place they can get affordable care. More people are turning to community health each year, and the reasons are not hard to find.
As the cost-of-living rises, so does the cost of care. Seeing a GP, a specialist or a psychologist has become harder to afford and harder to find close to home. When that happens, people don’t stop needing care. They come to us.
More Victorians are living with chronic conditions. Nearly half of us live with conditions like diabetes or heart disease.
Community health can support people living with chronic conditions at any point on their journey, and as their needs change, so does the support. The latest figures show that one in four clients now access more than one service from community health.
When someone with diabetes can see a nurse, a dietitian and a podiatrist under one roof, their condition is managed all year round and is less likely to result in a crisis visit to an emergency department.
And more people are looking for connection. Social isolation has increased substantially in Australia over the past two decades, and this disproportionately affects vulnerable populations.
Community health looks for ways to support better social connections, and three quarters of our clients say the support they get from community health makes them feel more connected.
Community health in Victoria’s safety net. But this brings its own pressures. Victoria’s population has grown 44 percent over two decades, but the hours of community healthcare available have grown by just 16 percent. That means less care per person, every year.
Thousands of Victorians are waiting for care they need now. Their health doesn’t pause while they wait, and too often, the next place they turn is an emergency department.
Victoria’s safety net: a community health service in action. Photo provided.
Where is the vision?
Good health is the foundation for a good life. But health is not just a physical issue. It is shaped by where people live, the jobs people have, and whether they have access to secure housing, affordable food, and strong social connections.
Community health is built on this understanding. Alongside GPs, nurses and allied health, community health offers counselling, family violence support, parenting programs, and help with housing, legal issues, gambling support and employment.
We look after the whole person, not just the first concern that brought them to our door.
Yet our broader health and social care system is still built and funded in silos. Health, housing, justice, and social services are funded separately, often through short term contracts, even though the evidence shows early intervention in these areas works.
There is a noticeable lack of vision from government and political parties on what a truly integrated system of care could look like. One that invests in prevention, joins up care across health and social services, and backs the organisations already doing the work.
Elections are a chance to set that vision. So far, this has been absent from the political discussion.
If we start with the essentials for a life well lived with a commitment to a more connected health and social care system, we can make real progress towards being the healthiest state in Australia.
Fixing the system doesn’t mean starting from scratch. It means properly funding the services that already keep Victorians well, long before they reach a hospital door.
Community health is a small part of the budget, but can be a big part of the solution for an unaffordable broken health system.
That is why the community health sector is asking all parties this election to commit to a better allocation of Victoria’s health funding, with a guaranteed minimum of one percent of the health budget for the Community Health Program.
It is a modest shift. But it would mean thousands more Victorians can get care close to home, sooner. It would also ease the burden on emergency departments by reaching people before they hit crisis point.
We don’t need a bigger health budget. We need a smarter one.
Author details
From L: Anna Robinson and Natalie Sullivan. Photos provided.
Anna Robinson is Chair of Community Health First, an initiative led by all 21 registered independent community health services in Victoria, and CEO of Access Health and Community.
Natalie Sullivan is Deputy Chair of Community Health First and CEO of Each.

See Croakey’s archive of articles on primary healthcare 
 
 

About the author

Asonblog

Add Comment

Click here to post a comment