A planned trial which would have seen a birthing unit team alternate between two hospitals in regional South Australia has been scrapped just weeks after it begun, with local GPs advising that they would not participate.
The ‘one team, one birthing site’ pilot was meant to operate between Jamestown and Crystal Brook hospitals, with each hospital spending about a month as the designated site before switching.
So far, the trial had only been operating on weekends.
According to a statement from Yorke and Northern Local Health Network, the pilot model was designed to “help with staff fatigue and manage regular diversions to alternate hospitals due to workforce shortages”.
The Medical Republic understands that the GPs were chiefly concerned with increased risk of errors in clinical handover between the two physical sites, as well as unintentional gaps.
Four doctors wrote to the state health minister expressing their concern earlier this year.
With the single site idea now scrapped, both Crystal Brook and Jamestown hospital birthing units will remain open.
In order to meet minimum staffing requirements set by SA Health, GP practices will roster individual doctors to cover emergency departments at Orroroo, Laura, Jamestown, and Crystal Brook, with additional doctors to cover obstetrics, anaesthetics, and neonatal support.
The local health network will “aim to provide additional doctors when this cannot be met”.
“The return to the previous birthing arrangement across two sites means that challenges in filling the roster across the two sites will continue into the future and will likely lead to diversions from one or both sites, potentially at short notice, as was previously the case,” the health network said.
Related
Common antibiotic linked to pregnancy loss
‘Change needed to be made’ in SA maternity units
Rotating maternity unit trial meets GP opposition
SA Health has been forced to pause birthing services at both hospitals a total of 41 times, spanning 137 days, between July 2025 and June 2026.
Most of these were due to temporary staff shortages.
“The bottom line is that we must ensure all our hospitals provide safe services,” Yorke and Northern Local Health Network board chair John Voumard said.
“It is an unacceptable risk to our community that a doctor can be on call at multiple sites concurrently and be unavailable to respond to an emergency.”
Crystal Brook and Jamestown hospitals are the only two sites across South Australia Health that are non-compliant with workforce requirements to have three appropriately credentialled medical practitioners rostered and available to respond to a Category 1 Caesarean section (one to perform the procedure, one to provide anaesthetic, and one to attend to the neonate).
Because they would have to be “available”, the doctors were unable to be rostered on multiple on-call roles at one time.
“These three functions require three separate doctors who are genuinely available at the same time and are not committed to another clinical responsibility that could prevent them responding when required,” SA Health CEO Dr Robyn Lawrence wrote in a letter responding to GP concerns earlier this year.
While clinicians may be credentialled across several areas of practice, she wrote, the issue at hand was whether all required clinicians would be simultaneously available when an obstetric emergency occurred.
“The risk of maternal or foetal complications or death due to non-compliance with these organisational requirements, is not accepted,” she wrote.
“As discussed with you and nursing staff in regular meetings with [Yorke and Northern Local Health Network], the revised work instruction is intended to address the risk of competing clinical demands, and ensure the provision of a safe, sustainable model of care.”
The post GP pushback halts rural maternity pilot appeared first on Medical Republic.











Add Comment